Recently, I was given the opportunity to upgrade my cell phone from a phone, to a smart phone.
After a lot of research and driving everyone I know crazy about what phone they have and what they like about it, I decided that I wanted either an I-Phone or a HTC Android. I decided against a blackberry only because I knew nothing of the blackberry operating system and from the look and feel of the 2 phones I saw, I just wasn’t sure.
I had the opportunity to look, feel, and use the I-phone as well as the I-pod touch, which I used for the last year for all my activities except for making phone calls and sending text messages.
The one thing I did not like about the I-phone was the touch key pad. I could not get onto the the fact that my fingers kept hitting the wrong keys and it took me twice as long to type anything. That could just be that I could not get onto the keyboard. I know others that had no trouble with that.
After having used the HTC Dream for a weekend, I really liked the phone, was easy to use and the flip keyboard was great.
I decided to get the HTC Magic, (I already had access to the Dream and thought I would try the other HTC phone) but this was all depended on the signal I could (or could not get lately) at work. After talking to Rogers, the HTC Magic was ordered with the agreement that it could be returned if I could not use it at work due to lack of signal. (I was using a Nokia E66 and would have to turn the phone off and on several times during the day to get signal to send text messages, forget even being able to make a phone call)
My Magic arrived on Thursday and upon opening it up, I discovered many differences between the Dream and the Magic.
|
Dream |
Magic |
| Size |
4.6 x 2.16 x 0.6 inch |
4.45 x 2.19 x 0.54 inch |
| Weight |
5.65 oz |
4.09 oz |
| Battery |
| Talk Time |
5.5 hrs |
6.5 hrs |
| Stand By Time |
15 days |
17 days |
| Memory |
|
256 Mb Expandable |
512 Mb Expandable |
|
Up to 16 Mb Micro SD |
Up to 16 Mb Micro SD |
| Signal |
GSM/GPRS/EDGE |
GSM/GPRS/EDGE |
| Keyboard |
Slide out QWERTY |
Touch |
In my opinion, I found the Magic easier to use. As a woman with smaller hands, I found the size and the weight of the Magic was much easier to handle. I found that the signal on the Magic is much better then my old Nokia phone.
So far, I have found that the battery life on the Magic is far longer then the battery life of the Dream, or even the I-pod Touch or the Nokia. Please remember that I am using the Magic as both my Phone and touch so it is getting much more use.
The hardest part of the Magic is getting use to the touch portion of the phone. Especially the keyboard. However, there is a program that will detect the word you are trying to type so if you hit a wrong key, you can choose the right word.
Android has a great shopping “Market” where you can download free apps and games for your phone, the same as you can with Apple, however, you are not limited to just Apple apps with the Android. The really nice thing is, each phone can be ‘customized’ for each user. Upon having the phone for less then 48hours, Steve rooted the phone and installed a custom build of Android which made the phone work better with less software issues I was having earlier.
In closing I liked the use of both the HTC phones, however, I prefer the weight and size of the Magic over the Dream, although for those preferring a QWERTY keyboard the HTC Dream is a nice alternative.
If you are in the market for buying a new phone, I hope this may help you.